LD 1295
pg. 46
Page 45 of 67 An Act To Enact the Uniform Mediation Act Page 47 of 67
Download Bill Text
LR 464
Item 1

 
exception makes it possible to use testimony of anyone except
the mediator in proceedings at which such a claim is made or
defended. Because of the potential adverse impact on a
mediator's appearance of impartiality, the use of mediator
testimony is more guarded, and therefore protected by Section
6(c). It is important to note that evidence fitting this
exception would still be protected in other types of
proceedings, such as those related to the dispute being
mediated.

 
Reporting requirements operate independently of the privilege
and this exception. Mediators and other are not precluded by
the Act from reporting misconduct to an agency or tribunal
other than one that might make a ruling on the dispute being
mediated, which is precluded by Section 8(a) and (b).

 
8. Section 6(a)(7). Evidence of abuse or neglect.

 
An exception for child abuse and neglect is common in domestic
mediation confidentiality statutes, and the Act reaffirms
these important policy choices States have made to protect
their citizens. See, e.g., Iowa. Code Ann. Section 679c.3(4)
(1998) (general); Kan. Stat. Ann. Section 23-605(b)(2) (1999)
(domestic relations); Kan. Stat. Ann. Section 38-1522(a)
(1997) (general); Kan. Stat. Ann. Section 44-817 )(2) (1996)
(labor); Kan. Stat. Ann. Section 72-5427(e)(2) (1996)
(teachers); Kan. Stat. Ann. Section 75-4332(d)(1) (1996)
(public employment); Minn. Stat. Ann. Section 595.02(2)(a)(5)
(1996) (general); Mont. Code Ann. Section 41-3-404 (1999)
(child abuse investigations) (mediator may not be compelled to
testify); Neb. Rev. Stat. Section 43-2908 (1993) (parenting
act) (in camera); N.H. Rev. Stat. Ann. Section 328-C:9(III)(c
) (1998) (marital); N.C. Gen. Stat. Section 7A-38.1(L) (1999)
(superior court); N.C. Gen. Stat. Section 7A-38.4(K) (1999)
(district courts); Ohio Rev. Code Ann. Section 3109.052(c)
(West 1990) (child custody); Ohio Rev. Code Ann. Section
5123.601 (West 1988) (mental retardation); Ohio Rev. Code Ann.
Section 2317.02 (1998) (general); Or. Rev. Stat. Section
36.220(5) (1997) (general); Tenn. Code Ann. Section 36-4-
130(b)(5) (1993) (divorce); Utah Code Ann. Section 30-3-38(4)
(2000) (divorce) (mediator shall report); Va. Code Ann.
Section 63.1-248.3(A)(10) (2000) (welfare); Wis. Stat. Section
48.981(2) (1997) (social services): Wis. Stat. Section
904.085(4)(d) (1997) (general); Wyo. Stat. Section 1-43-
103(c)(iii) (1991) (general). But see Ariz. Rev. Stat. Ann.
Section 8-807(B) (West 1998) (child abuse investigations)
(rejecting rule of disclosure).

 
By referring to "child and adult protective services agency,"
the exception broadens the coverage to include the elderly and
disabled if that State has protected them by statute and has
created an agency enforcement process. It should be stressed
that this exception applies only to permit disclosures in
public


Page 45 of 67 Top of Page Page 47 of 67