LD 1295
pg. 41
Page 40 of 67 An Act To Enact the Uniform Mediation Act Page 42 of 67
Download Bill Text
LR 464
Item 1

 
would not be a signed agreement. On the other hand, the
following situations would be considered a signed agreement: a
handwritten agreement that the parties have signed, an e-mail
exchange between the parties in which they agree to particular
provisions, and a tape recording in which they state what
constitutes their agreement.

 
Written agreements are commonly excepted from mediation
confidentiality protections, permitting the Act to embrace
current practices in a majority of States. See Ariz. Rev.
Stat. Ann. Section 12-2238 (1993); Cal. Evid. Code Section
1120(1) (West 1997) (general); Cal. Evid. Code Section 1123
(West 1997) (general); Cal. Gov't. Code Section 12980(i) (West
1998) (housing discrimination); Colo. Rev. Stat. Section 24-
34-506.5 (1993) (housing discrimination); Ga. Code Ann.
Section 45-19-36(e) (1989) (fair employment); 775 Ill. Comp.
Stat. Section 5/7B-102(E)(3) (1989) (human rights); Ind. Code
Section 679.2 (1998) (general); Iowa. Code Ann. Section
216.15(B) (1999) (civil rights); Ky. Rev. Stat. Ann. Section
344.200(4) (1996) (civil rights); La. Rev. Stat. Ann. Section
9:4112(B)(1)(c) (1997) (general); La. Rev. Stat. Ann. Section
51:2257(D) (1998) (human rights); 5 Me. Rev. Stat. Ann.
Section 4612(1)(A) (1995) (human rights); Md. Code 1957 Ann.
Art. 49(B) Section 28 (1991) (human rights); Mass. Gen. Laws.
ch. 151B, Section 5 (1991) (job discrimination); Mo. Rev.
Stat. Section 213.077 (1992) (human rights); Neb. Rev. Stat.
Section 43-2908 (1993) (parenting act); N.J. Stat. Ann.
Section 10:5-14 (1992) (civil rights); Or. Rev. Stat. Ann.
Section 36.220(2)(a) (1997) (general); Or. Rev. Stat. Ann.
36.262 (1989) (agricultural foreclosure); 42 Pa. Consol. Stat.
Section 5949(b)(1) (1996) (general); Tenn. Code Ann. Section
4-21-303(d) (1996) (human rights); Tex. Gov't. Code Ann.
Section 2008.057 (1999) (Administrative Procedure Act); Vt. R.
Civ. P., Rule 16.3 (1998) (general civil); Va. Code Ann.
Section 8.01-576.10 (1994) (general); Va. Code Ann. Section
8.01-581.22 ( 1988) (general); Wash. Rev. Code Section
5.60.070 (1)(e) and (f) (1993) ( 1993) (general); Wash. Rev.
Code Section 26.09.015(3) (1991) (divorce); Wash. Rev. Code
Section 49.60.240 (1995) (human rights); W.Va. Code Section 5-
11A-11(b)(4) (1992) (fair housing); W.Va. Code Section 6B-2-
4(r) (1990) (public employees); Wis. Stat. Section 767.11(12)
(1993) (family court); Wis. Stat. Section 904.085(4)(a) (1997)
(general).

 
This exception is noteworthy only for what is not included:
oral agreements. The disadvantage of exempting oral
settlements is that nearly everything said during a mediation
session could bear on either whether the parties came to an
agreement or the content of the agreement. In other words, an
exception for oral agreements has the potential to swallow the
rule of privilege.
As a result, mediation participants might be less candid, not
knowing whether a controversy later would erupt over an oral


Page 40 of 67 Top of Page Page 42 of 67