Amend the bill by striking out everything after the enacting clause and before the summary and inserting the following:
PART A
‘
Sec. 1. 31 MRSA c. 13, as amended, is repealed.
Sec. A-2. 31 MRSA c. 21 is enacted to read:
CHAPTER 21
LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANIES
SUBCHAPTER 1
GENERAL PROVISIONS
This chapter may be known and cited as "the Maine Limited Liability Company Act."
As used in this chapter, unless the context otherwise indicates, the following terms have the following meanings.
The law of this State governs:
SUBCHAPTER 2
LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AGREEMENT; PROVISIONS OF CHAPTER THAT MAY NOT BE MODIFIED BY THE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AGREEMENT
SUBCHAPTER 3
FORMATION, CERTIFICATE OF FORMATION AND OTHER FILINGS
SUBCHAPTER 4
RELATIONS OF MEMBERS TO PERSONS DEALING WITH LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
A person may not bind a limited liability company except:
A person named in a filed statement of authority may deliver to the office of the Secretary of State for filing a statement of denial that:
A person who is a member of a limited liability company is not liable, solely by reason of being a member, under a judgment, decree or order of a court, or in any other manner, for a debt, obligation or liability of the limited liability company, whether arising in contract, tort or otherwise or for the acts or omissions of any other member, agent or employee of the limited liability company.
SUBCHAPTER 5
RELATIONS OF MEMBERS TO EACH OTHER AND TO LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
A contribution may consist of cash, property or services rendered or a promissory note or other obligation to contribute cash or property or to perform services.
A limited liability company may indemnify and hold harmless a member or other person, pay in advance or reimburse expenses incurred by a member or other person and purchase and maintain insurance on behalf of a member or other person.
Except as may be set forth in the limited liability company agreement in accordance with sections 1521 and 1522, the following provisions apply.
A professional limited liability company, as defined in Title 13, section 723, subsection 5, is subject to the Maine Professional Service Corporation Act except as follows.
SUBCHAPTER 6
TRANSFERABLE INTERESTS AND RIGHTS OF TRANSFEREES AND CREDITORS
The only interest of a member that is transferable is the member's transferable interest. A transferable interest in a limited liability company is personal property.
If a member dies, the deceased member's personal representative or other legal representative may, for purposes of settling the estate, exercise the rights of a current member under section 1558.
SUBCHAPTER 7
MEMBER'S DISSOCIATION
A person is dissociated as a member from a limited liability company when:
SUBCHAPTER 8
DISSOLUTION, WINDING UP, REINSTATEMENT AND REVIVAL
Notwithstanding Title 4, chapter 5 and Title 5, chapter 375, the Secretary of State may commence a proceeding under section 1592 to administratively dissolve a domestic limited liability company if:
After dissolution, a limited liability company is bound by:
Upon the winding up of a limited liability company, the assets must be applied as follows.
SUBCHAPTER 9
LOW-PROFIT LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANIES
SUBCHAPTER 10
FOREIGN LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANIES
Notwithstanding Title 4, chapter 5 and Title 5, chapter 375, the Secretary of State may commence a proceeding under section 1626 to revoke a statement of foreign qualification if:
SUBCHAPTER 11
ACTIONS BY MEMBERS
A member may maintain a derivative action to enforce a right of a limited liability company if:
In a derivative action under section 1632 the complaint must state with particularity:
SUBCHAPTER 12
MERGER AND CONVERSION
This subchapter does not preclude an entity from being merged or converted under law other than this chapter.
SUBCHAPTER 13
ADMINISTRATIVE PROVISIONS
A domestic limited liability company must have and continuously maintain a registered agent in this State as defined by Title 5, section 102, subsection 27.
Service of process, notice or demand required or permitted by law on a domestic limited liability company is governed by Title 5, section 113.
The principal office of a limited liability company or foreign limited liability company need not be located in this State.
The Secretary of State has the power reasonably necessary to perform the duties required of the Secretary of State by this chapter, including the power to adopt rules not inconsistent with this chapter. Rules adopted pursuant to this chapter are routine technical rules as defined in Title 5, chapter 375, subchapter 2-A.
The Secretary of State may provide an expedited service for the processing of documents in accordance with this chapter. If the service is provided, the Secretary of State shall establish by rule a fee schedule and governing procedures in accordance with the Maine Administrative Procedure Act. Fees collected for expedited service must be deposited into a fund for use by the Secretary of State in providing an improved filing service.
The Secretary of State may provide public access to the database through a medium approved by the Secretary of State, through public terminals and through electronic duplicates of the database. If access to the database is provided to the public, the Secretary of State may adopt rules in accordance with the Maine Administrative Procedure Act to establish a fee schedule and governing procedures.
Each document authorized or required to be delivered to the Secretary of State for filing under this chapter must satisfy the following requirements and the requirements of any other section of this chapter.
Except as otherwise provided in section 1675 and Title 5, section 111, a record delivered to the office of the Secretary of State for filing under this chapter may specify an effective time and a delayed effective date. Subject to section 1675 and Title 5, section 111, a record filed by the Secretary of State is effective:
Whenever a provision of this subchapter requires that a document for filing state an address, the document must state:
A document filed under this chapter is not effective until the applicable fee required in this section is paid. The following fees or penalties must be paid to the office of the Secretary of State:
All fees collected as provided by this chapter must be remitted to the Treasurer of State for the use of the State with the exception of those fees established by rule and collected for expedited service. Fees for expedited service are deposited into a fund for use by the Secretary of State in providing an improved filing service.
SUBCHAPTER 14
MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS
This chapter modifies, limits and supersedes the federal Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act, 15 United States Code, Section 7001 et seq., but does not modify, limit or supersede Section 101(c) of that Act, 15 United States Code, Section 7001(c), or authorize electronic delivery of any of the notices described in Section 103(b) of that Act, 15 United States Code, Section 7003(b).
Sec. A-3. Effective date. This Act takes effect July 1, 2011.
PART B
Sec. B-1. 9-B MRSA §311, as amended by PL 2005, c. 543, Pt. D, §1 and affected by §18, is further amended to read:
The provisions of this chapter govern the organization and management of financial institutions operating as corporations, limited liability companies, limited partnerships and limited liability partnerships. Unless otherwise indicated in this Title, the provisions of Title 13-C apply to financial institutions operating as corporations; Title 31, chapter 19 applies to financial institutions operating as limited partnerships; Title 31, chapter 13 21 applies to financial institutions operating as limited liability companies; and Title 31, chapter 15 applies to financial institutions operating as limited liability partnerships.
Sec. B-2. 9-B MRSA §316-A, first ¶, as amended by PL 2005, c. 543, Pt. D, §2 and affected by §18, is further amended to read:
Except as provided in this section, the management and operations of a financial institution organized under this chapter are governed by Title 13-C; Title 31, chapter 19; Title 31, chapter 13 21; or Title 31, chapter 15, as appropriate, depending upon the organizational form of the financial institution operating under this chapter. The institution's organizational documents must address the powers and duties of the governing body.
Sec. B-3. 9-B MRSA §317-A, first ¶, as amended by PL 2005, c. 543, Pt. D, §3 and affected by §18, is further amended to read:
Except as provided in this section, the powers and duties of officers of a financial institution organized under this chapter are governed by Title 13-C; Title 31, chapter 19; Title 31, chapter 13 21; or Title 31, chapter 15, as appropriate, depending upon the organizational form of the financial institution operating under this chapter. The institution's organizational documents must address the powers and duties of officers.
Sec. B-4. 9-B MRSA §352, sub-§5, as amended by PL 2005, c. 543, Pt. D, §4 and affected by §18, is further amended to read:
Sec. B-5. 9-B MRSA §1222, sub-§1, as amended by PL 2005, c. 543, Pt. D, §5 and affected by §18, is further amended to read:
Sec. B-6. 10 MRSA §1521, sub-§2-B, as amended by PL 2003, c. 344, Pt. A, §4, is further amended to read:
Sec. B-7. 31 MRSA §7, as amended by PL 2007, c. 535, Pt. A, §3 and affected by §7, is further amended to read:
Sections 1 and 2 do not apply to corporations, limited partnerships or limited liability companies. A corporation desiring to do business under an assumed name shall file a statement as provided in Title 13-C, section 404. A limited partnership desiring to do business under an assumed name shall file a statement as provided in section 1308, subsection 2. A limited liability company desiring to do business under an assumed name shall file a statement as provided in section 605-A 1510.
Sec. B-8. 31 MRSA §876, as amended by PL 2005, c. 543, Pt. D, §17 and affected by §18, is further amended to read:
All foreign limited liability partnerships qualified as foreign corporations or limited partnerships or limited liability companies before September 1, 1996 are governed by this Act on and after September 1, 1996. By December 1, 1996 a partner of each foreign limited liability partnership shall file with the Secretary of State an application for authority to do business in this State under this Act and shall cancel the partnership's authority to do business in this State under chapter 19, former chapter 13 or former Title 13-A. If the foreign limited liability partnership fails to file the new application for authority to do business in this State by December 1, 1996, it must be treated as a general partnership without the status of a limited liability partnership with respect to any business conducted in this State between December 1, 1996 and the date on which it files that application.
Sec. B-9. 36 MRSA §5180, sub-§1, as enacted by PL 1999, c. 414, §41, is amended to read:
Sec. B-10. 36 MRSA §5180, sub-§2, as enacted by PL 1999, c. 414, §41, is repealed.
summary
This amendment replaces the bill. It repeals the existing Maine Limited Liability Company Act, currently the Maine Revised Statutes, Title 31, chapter 13, and replaces it with a new Maine Limited Liability Company Act. This summary contains a detailed explanation of the new limited liability company act and how it differs from the provisions of the predecessor Act. Information contained in this summary is consistent with information that would be provided in comments that are part of a uniform act.
GENERAL COMMENTS
The new Maine Limited Liability Company Act fundamentally differs from its predecessor. Its predecessor diminished the role of the operating agreement. Under the predecessor Act, a limited liability company could be formed even without an operating agreement. Further, the predecessor Act limited the ability of the members to tailor the operating agreement to deal terms.
This Act elevates the status of the operating agreement, known as the limited liability company agreement, giving it a central role in the existence and operation of a limited liability company, LLC. A limited liability company cannot be formed without an operating agreement. Further, under this Act, with few limited exceptions, the limited liability company agreement governs the relations among members and between the members and the company.
Because the operating agreement plays such a key role, subchapter 2 is of central importance. Subchapter 2 concerns the operating agreement, and it is the heart of the Act. It establishes that the operating agreement determines the rights and obligations of members and transferees. It also permits members to shape duties, define liability for breach of duty and establish whether and to what degree persons will be indemnified against liability.
The emphasis on the operating agreement reflects the view that the limited liability company is a contractual entity and that the Act permits and facilitates the molding of provisions to the contours of a particular deal and the interests of the members. Ordinary contract principles and equitable doctrines check the ability of one party to unfairly disadvantage another by contract. In this sense, the operating agreement is like any other contract.
While this Act fundamentally differs from its predecessor in significant ways, many of its provisions perfectly or nearly perfectly continue provisions of its predecessor. For example, most of the administrative provisions, subchapter 13, are drawn from the Act’s predecessor. Practitioners will know many provisions of this Act by reference to provisions of the Act’s predecessor.
SUBCHAPTER COMMENTS
SUBCHAPTER 1 - GENERAL PROVISIONS
SECTION 1502. DEFINITIONS
Certificate of formation - The term “articles of organization” used in the American Bar Association Revised Limited Liability Company Prototype Act, the prototype, has been replaced with “certificate of formation.” The certificate of formation is reflective of the contract nature of the limited liability company and thus the terms of the member’s contract are expected to be included in the limited liability company agreement and not in the certificate of formation. This follows the pattern set forth in Delaware’s LLC Act, the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act and the Uniform Act.
Foreign limited liability company - This term is derived from the DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, § 18-101(4).
Limited liability company - This definition reflects the move to a Delaware-style limited liability company in that it requires a limited liability company agreement to be present. In addition, by definition, the fact that a limited liability company has a certificate of formation on file with the Secretary of State and has one or more members is conclusive evidence that a limited liability agreement exists. This conclusion results from the understanding that a limited liability company cannot operate without an agreement by the members regarding the limited liability company’s operations.
The Uniform Act’s proposal to allow for an entity called a shelf LLC is not adopted in this Act. The shelf LLC can exist without any members or an agreement. Under the Uniform Act, the shelf LLC automatically terminates if the limited liability company does not have any members within the 90-day period beginning on the date its certificate of organization, the articles of organization equivalent under the Uniform Act, is filed with the Secretary of State.
Permitting a limited liability company to exist without members or an agreement arguably changes the nature of the limited liability company from a creature of contract to a more corporate-type entity. The drafting committee members were persuaded that this argument could be used as a basis for rulings that disregard or give reduced weight to the doctrine that permits limited liability company members to choose those with whom they co-venture. This is the doctrine of delectus personae, and it is a fundamental doctrine in partnership-derived entities such as the limited liability company. The ruling of In re Ashley Albright, 2003 Bankr. Lexis 291 (Bank. D.Colo. April 4, 2003) deserves attention.
In addition, because of the ability to file a certificate of formation within 24 hours or less, the Act does not provide for shelf entities.
Limited liability company agreement - Using this term, as opposed to operating agreement, reflects a combination of Colorado and Delaware law and conforms the agreement name to that of other unincorporated entities, for example, partnership agreement and limited partnership agreement. The parties may refer to the agreement as an operating agreement, however.
This Act states no rule as to whether the statute of frauds applies to an oral operating agreement. Case law suggests that an oral agreement to form a partnership or joint venture with a term exceeding one year is within the statute. E.g. Abbott v. Hurst, 643 So.2d 589, 592 (Ala. 1994), "Partnership agreements, like other contracts, are subject to the Statute of Frauds. A contract of partnership for a term exceeding one year is within the Statute of Frauds and is void unless it is in writing; however, a contract establishing a partnership terminable at the will of any partner is generally held to be capable of performance by its terms within one year of its making and, therefore, to be outside the Statute of Frauds." (citations omitted); Pemberton v. Ladue Realty & Const. Co., 362 Mo. 768, 770-71, 244 S.W.2d 62, 64 (Mo. 1951), rejecting plaintiff's contention that mere part performance sufficed to take the oral agreement outside the statute and holding that partnership was therefore at will; Ebker v. Tan Jay Int'l, Ltd., 739 F.2d 812, 827-28 (2d Cir.1984), the same analysis with regard to a joint venture. However, it is not possible to form an LLC without someone signing and delivering to the filing officer a certificate of formation in record form, section 1541, and the Act itself then establishes the LLC's duration. Subject to the operating agreement, that duration is perpetual, section 1504, subsection 3. An oral provision of an operating agreement calling for performance that extends beyond a year might be within the one-year provision, for example an oral agreement that a particular member will serve and be permitted to serve as manager for 3 years.
An oral provision of an operating agreement that involves the transfer of land, whether by or to the LLC, might come within the land provision of the statute of frauds. Froiseth v. Nowlin, 156 Wash. 314, 316, 287 P. 55. 56 (Wash. 1930), "[The land provision] applies to an oral contract to transfer or convey partnership real property, and the interest of the other partners therein, to one partner as an individual, as well as to a parole contract by one of the parties to convey certain land owned by him individually to the partnership, or to another partner, or to put it into the partnership stock." (quoting 27 Corpus Juris 220)
In contrast, the fact that a limited liability company owns or deals in real property does not bring within the land provision agreements pertaining to the LLC's membership interests. Interests in a limited liability company are personal property and reflect no direct interest in the entity's assets. Thus, the real property issues pertaining to the LLC's ownership of land do not flow through to the members and membership interests. See, e.g., Wooten v. Marshall, 153 F. Supp. 759, 763-764 (S.D. N.Y. 1957), involving an "oral agreement for a joint venture concerning the purchase, exploitation and eventual disposition of this 160 acre tract" and stating "[t]he real property acquired and dealt with by the venturers takes on the character of personal property as between the partners in the enterprise, and hence is not covered by [the Statute of Frauds]."
Member - This definition was modified to reflect the Delaware definition in an effort to avoid confusion over the nondefined phrase "dissociated member."
Person - This definition reflects Delaware's more expansive definition, DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, section 18-101(12); however, the drafting committee determined not to include groups, boards, councils or committees in the definition of "person."
SECTION 1503. KNOWLEDGE; NOTICE
Subsection 2 reflects the broader view of notice as captured by the RESTATEMENT (THIRD) OF AGENCY § 5.01, Title 31, section 1002 of the Uniform Partnership Act and Title 31, section 1303 of the Uniform Limited Partnership Act of 2007.
Subsection 5 clarifies that a member's knowledge, notice or receipt of a notification of a fact in such member's sole capacity as a member would not be imputed to the LLC. If the member is an agent of the company, i.e., an officer or other agent, then such notice may be imputed to the LLC via the law of agency.
SECTION 1504. NATURE, PURPOSE AND DURATION OF LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
The use of LLCs for nonprofit activities is authorized by this Act; however, as with all LLC acts, careful attention to drafting of the LLC agreement is required to meet the tax requirements of the various taxing authorities.
SECTION 1505. CAPACITIES AND POWERS
Subsection 2 reflects the view of the prototype that the capacity to hold property in the LLC's own name is one of the tests of an entity.
SECTION 1506. GOVERNING LAW
Section 1506 is reflective of the internal affairs doctrine, which is universally applied in business entity statutes.
SECTION 1507. RULES OF CONSTRUCTION
Subsection 5 is derived from DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, §18-1101 (g) and VA. CODE ANN. §13.1-1001.1(B).
SECTION 1508. NAME
To the extent that other law requires professionals, banks or other entities or individuals to utilize certain names in the name of the LLC to conduct activities in an LLC, such other law should be followed in determining the name; however, the name must nevertheless contain the words "limited liability company" or "limited company" or the abbreviation L.L.C., LLC, L.C. or LC. "Limited" may be abbreviated as "Ltd.," and "company" may be abbreviated as "Co."
Subsection 4 is derived from COLO. REV. STAT. ANN. § 7-90-601.6.
Subsections 5 and 6 are derived from COLO. REV. STAT. ANN. § 7-90-601.
SUBCHAPTER 2 - LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AGREEMENT
Subchapter 2 is the heart of the Act. Subject to certain exceptions, the limited liability company agreement governs relations among the members and between the members and the limited liability company. The applicable default rules apply only to the extent that the limited liability company agreement does not otherwise provide for such a matter.
SECTION 1521. LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AGREEMENT; SCOPE, FUNCTION AND CERTAIN LIMITATIONS
The provisions of section 1521 establish that the agreement of the members as expressed in the limited liability company agreement controls; the default rules of the Act merely backstop the agreement to the extent the agreement does not address a matter.
Section 1521 is derived from DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, § 18-1101(b), (d) and (e).
Section 1521 qualifies the power of members to make a binding agreement. Subsection 3 provides that the members may not agree to eliminate the implied contractual covenant of good faith and fair dealing.
Additional limitations with regard to low-profit limited liability companies are included in section 1611.
SECTION 1522. PROVISIONS OF THE CHAPTER THAT MAY NOT BE MODIFIED BY THE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AGREEMENT
Section 1522 provides that the limited liability company agreement will not govern as to certain discrete matters; rather the matters listed in this section will be governed by the applicable provisions of this chapter.
Subsection 2 clarifies that the members may not agree to eliminate liability for a bad faith violation of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.
SECTION 1523. LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AGREEMENT; EFFECT ON LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AND PERSONS ADMITTED AS MEMBERS; PREFORMATION AGREEMENT
The language specifying that a person becomes a party to the limited liability company agreement upon admission as a member is intended to make clear that the member is bound by and may enforce the agreement.
SECTION 1524. LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AGREEMENT; EFFECT ON 3RD PARTIES AND RELATIONSHIP TO RECORDS EFFECTIVE ON BEHALF OF LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
Subsection 1 is derived from DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, § 18-302(e). Subsection 2 is derived from DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, §18-101(7).
SUBCHAPTER 3 - FORMATION; CERTIFICATE OF FORMATION AND OTHER FILINGS
SECTION 1531. FORMATION OF LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY; CERTIFICATE OF FORMATION
Subsection 3 sets forth the notice effect of the certificate of formation and follows the approach of DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, § 18-207.
SECTION 1532. AMENDMENT OR RESTATEMENT OF CERTIFICATE OF FORMATION
The last sentence of subsection 4 is derived from DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, § 18-208(d). Subsection 5 is derived from DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, §18-208(e).
SUBCHAPTER 4 - RELATIONS OF MEMBERS TO PERSONS DEALING WITH LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
SECTION 1541. POWER TO BIND LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
Most states' LLC acts, including the predecessor Act, force LLC members to designate either members or managers as those having apparent authority to bind the LLC. In addition, the Maine Limited Liability Company Act forces members into a management structure based upon their apparent authority designation: if the members designate the members as persons having power to bind the LLC, the LLC is, by default, member-run; if the members designate managers as persons having power to bind the LLC, the LLC is a manager-run entity. See Title 31, sections 622 and 651. In this way, apparent authority and actual authority are, by default, linked.
The Uniform Act and the prototype reflect the consensus among academics and commentators that apparent authority and actual authority in LLCs should be delinked. Accordingly, the certificate of formation does not require a designation of persons with apparent authority. Further, the management structure of the LLC is not governed by a designation by the LLC of a person with apparent authority.
Section 1541 sets forth the ways in which a person has authority to bind the LLC. Subsection 1 provides guidance to 3rd parties who wish to determine who has the authority to bind the LLC. Section 1541 generally follows the prototype, with one significant addition. Subsection 4 provides that, in the absence of an effective statement of authority, any member, manager, president or treasurer has authority to bind the LLC. The purpose of such a broad provision is to facilitate commercial transactions. It is fully expected that neither LLCs, their members nor 3rd parties will rely on this provision as a matter of practice. It is expected that most LLCs will file statements of authority designating those persons or officers with apparent authority.
SECTION 1542. STATEMENT OF AUTHORITY
This section is derived from the Revised Uniform Partnership Act, § 303. Subsection 1 describes the elements of the statement. Subsection 3 allows an LLC to describe limitations on authority.
SUBCHAPTER 5 - RELATIONS OF MEMBERS TO EACH OTHER AND TO LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
SECTION 1551. ADMISSION OF A MEMBER
Subsection 1 is derived from DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, §18-301.
SECTION 1552. FORM OF CONTRIBUTION
This section is derived from DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, §18-501.
SECTION 1553. LIABILITY FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
Subsection 3 is derived from DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, §18-502(b).
SECTION 1554. SHARING OF AND RIGHT TO DISTRIBUTIONS
Distributions made pursuant to this section are subject to outstanding charging orders under section 1573.
SECTION 1555. LIMITATIONS ON DISTRIBUTION AND LIABILITY FOR IMPROPER DISTRIBUTIONS
This section is similar to DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, §18-607 and provisions in other states. It avoids imposing liability based on authorization or consent to distribution.
The exception in subsection 4 applies only for the purposes of this section. The exception is derived from existing statutory provisions. See, e.g., DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, § 18-607(a) (2006) and VA. CODE ANN., § 13.1-1035(E) (West 2006). See also In re Tri-River Trading, LLC, 329 B.R. 252, 266, (8th Cir. BAP 2005), aff'd. 452 F.3d 756 (8th Cir. 2006), "We know of no principle of law which suggests that a manager of a company is required to give up agreed upon salary to pay creditors when business turns bad."
Subsection 5 is derived from the Maine Business Corporation Act, Title 13-C, section 651, subsection 8.
SECTION 1556. ACTIVITIES AND AFFAIRS OF LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
Decision making is the focus of this section rather than agency power. Agency power will result from action of the decision makers. Language from the partnership context that arguably implies each member is an agent with authority to act in the absence of reason to know of a disagreement has been avoided.
SECTION 1557. INDEMNIFICATION, ADVANCEMENT, REIMBURSEMENT AND INSURANCE
This section is derived from Texas indemnity language from the TEXAS BUS. & COM. §101.402.
SECTION 1558. RIGHT OF MEMBERS AND DISSOCIATED MEMBERS TO INFORMATION
Although the rights and duties stated in this section are extensive, they may not necessarily be exhaustive. In some situations, some courts have seen owners' information rights as reflecting a fiduciary duty of those with management power.
Subsection 2 does not control the rights of the estate of a member who dissociates by dying. In that circumstance, section 1574 controls.
In subsection 6, the phrase "as a matter within the ordinary course of its activities" means that a mere majority consent is needed to impose a restriction or condition. This approach is necessary, lest a requesting member have the power to block imposition of a reasonable restriction or condition needed to prevent the requestor from abusing the LLC.
SECTION 1559. DUTIES OF MEMBERS AND OTHER PERSONS
This section is derived from the Maine Limited Liability Company Act, Title 31, section 652. This section is intended to overrule Rosenthal v. Rosenthal, 543 A.2d 348, 355 (Me. 1988) to the extent Rosenthal applies to duties in LLCs.
SUBCHAPTER 6 - TRANSFERABLE INTERESTS AND RIGHTS OF TRANSFEREES AND CREDITORS
SECTION 1571. MEMBER'S TRANSFERABLE INTEREST
Section 1571 is derived from section 501 of RULLCA.
This Act does not provide that "[p]roperty transferred to or otherwise acquired by a limited liability company is property of the limited liability company and not of the members individually." This language, found in earlier model LLC Acts, was found to be no longer necessary in this Act based on the general state of the law of limited liability companies in which it is the common understanding that a limited liability company is an entity and its properties are not owned by its members.
The member's transferable interest is defined in section 1502, subsection 29 to include the member's financial rights, that is, the member's right to receive distributions. The member's transferable interest differs from the member's broader rights in the limited liability company. A member has both governance rights to participate in management and control and financial rights to receive distributions. In order to clarify the rights of members, transferees, creditors and heirs, this section defines what a member conveys by transfer in the absence of a contrary agreement. The most important differences between members' rights and their transferable interests are that the latter do not include the rights to participate in management and control and to inspect the books and records of the limited liability company.
Whether the Maine Uniform Commercial Code, Article 8-A, Article 9-A or both govern a transferable interest pledged as security depends on the facts and the rules stated in those Articles. However, section 1507, subsection 5 clearly provides that sections 9-1406 and 9-1408 of Title 11 do not apply to an interest in a limited liability company, including all rights, powers and interests assigned under a limited liability company agreement.
SECTION 1572. TRANSFER OF TRANSFERABLE INTEREST
Section 1572 is derived from section 502 of the Uniform Act.
Subsection 1. Unlike a corporate shareholder, as a default rule, an LLC member can freely transfer only financial rights. Because transfer of a transferable interest transfers only financial rights, it follows that a transfer does not constitute a change in membership and therefore does not dissolve the LLC. Paragraph C of this subsection is intended to deny transferees of transferable interests not only voting and management rights, but also rights to information. Some limited liability companies may want to give transferees a right to compel winding up to prevent them from being completely frozen in and a right to information they need for federal and state income tax purposes and to protect them from unfair dealing by the members.
Subsection 2. The Act does not specifically define the distributions to which transferees have a right. A transferee would probably expect to receive, in the absence of contrary agreement, a financial interest equal to that of the transferor, including the transferor's capital contribution, if any, and residual claim to the assets of the limited liability company after all fixed claims, including debts to members, have been paid. It does not include rights the member has other than on account of the member's capital investment, such as repayment of loans, indemnification and accrued salaries.
Subsection 3. This section is a combination of DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, §18-702(c) and the earlier version of the prototype, §704(B). Even without such a provision, there is arguably no statutory impediment to issuing certificates. Issuing certificates may facilitate the transfer of transferable interests and thus, certification may be a desirable feature for many limited liability companies; however, the use of certificates can raise issues relating to Title 11, Article 8-A.
Under subsection 5, the transferor retains management and information rights notwithstanding the transfer. Subsection 6 clarifies that a transferee of a transferable interest does not have any of the obligations of a member until the transferee is admitted as a member voluntarily, at which point the transferee acquires obligations as well as rights of membership known to the transferee at the time the transferee voluntarily became a member. Subsection 6 protects the transferee from liabilities that might otherwise be imposed upon it should it become a member involuntarily.
SECTION 1573. CHARGING ORDER
This section is derived from section 503 of the Uniform Act.
This section provides that unsecured creditors can obtain from a court a charging order, which is similar to an attachment or garnishment, against the member's transferable interest. Under this section, the charging order is available only to judgment creditors of members or transferees. Under the predecessor Act, only judgment creditors of members may seek a charging order, section 686 of the predecessor Act. A charging order under this Act is not available to others with rights against members or transferees other than those of judgment creditors. The phrase "judgment debtor" encompasses both members and transferees. This section attempts to balance the needs of the judgment creditor, the judgment debtor and the limited liability company. The section achieves that balance by allowing the judgment creditor to collect on the judgment through the transferable interest of the judgment debtor while prohibiting interference in the management and activities of the limited liability company.
Subsection 1. This subsection provides the judgment creditor with the right to receive any distribution that the judgment debtor would have received, but only after the limited liability company has been served with the charging order. This subsection attempts to balance the interests of the judgment creditor and the LLC by defining what the judgment creditor was entitled to receive from the limited liability company while protecting the limited liability company from unknown charging orders.
Subsection 2. This provision provides a method for the limited liability company to pay a distribution pursuant to a charging order and discharge the limited liability company and the judgment debtor to the extent of the payment. This provision also anticipates that the judgment creditor may have a number of sources for the payment of its judgment and thus provides a mechanism to protect the limited liability company, the judgment debtor and the judgment creditor in the event a distribution exceeds the amount then owed to the judgment creditor. The judgment creditor has no say in the timing or amount of the distributions. The charging order does not entitle the judgment creditor to accelerate any distributions or to otherwise interfere with the management and activities of the limited liability company.
Subsection 3. This provision provides the judgment creditor with a lien for purposes of the Uniform Commercial Code, the Federal Bankruptcy Act and general creditor rights laws. This lien is also important in the context of a merger, conversion, reorganization or other transfers of transferable interests. In the proper circumstances, such an organic change might trigger an order by the court to enforce its charging order or might give rise to a separate cause of action against the LLC, the judgment debtor or the other holders of transferable interests.
The priority of the lien as to other creditors is determined under applicable law and is not addressed in this Act. The lien cannot be foreclosed upon as other liens. This removes a significant amount of issues presented by other statutes that attempt to provide rights of redemption and other preforeclosure and postforeclosure remedies. These rights were seen as clumsy and not effective in assisting in the collection of the debt while maintaining the integrity of the LLC and avoiding the intrusiveness of some statutes regarding creditor's rights to obtain overly broad court orders that have the effect of interfering with the day-to-day activities of the LLC. This lack of right to foreclose is reinforced in subsection 6 of this section.
Subsection 4. This provision clarifies that a judgment debtor that has a charging order against its transferable interest does not lose any of its rights, other than the right to receive distributions from the limited liability company to the extent of the charging order.
Subsection 5. This provision gives the judgment debtor the benefit of any exemptions applicable under Maine law with respect to the transferable interests; however, the extent of such exemptions varies from state to state.
Subsection 6. This provision is based upon DEL. CODE ANN., TIT. 6, §18-1705(3) and TEXAS BUS. & COM., §101.112(f).
Subsection 7. This provision simply limits the remedies of a judgment creditor as to the transferable interest of a judgment debtor. This provision was not intended, nor should it be interpreted, to prevent a court from enforcing its charging order in the event of a violation of the charging order by the judgment debtor or the limited liability company.
SECTION 1574. POWER OF PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF DECEASED MEMBER
This section is derived from section 504 of the Uniform Act.
SUBCHAPTER 7 - MEMBER'S DISSOCIATION
SECTION 1581. MEMBER'S POWER TO DISSOCIATE; WRONGFUL DISSOCIATION
This section is derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1374, which is based on the Maine Uniform Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1062.
SECTION 1582. EVENTS CAUSING DISSOCIATION
Subsection 11 was added to clarify that the transfer of a member's entire transferable interest causes a dissociation, but only at the later of the transferee becoming a member and the transfer being completed. Subsection 4, paragraph B is intended to deal with the issue of a transfer of a member's entire transferable interest to a current member, as opposed to a transfer to a person who is then not a member.
SECTION 1583. EFFECT OF PERSON'S DISSOCIATION AS A MEMBER
Subsection 1 is derived from COLO. REV. STAT., § 7-80-603. The Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1372 and the Maine Uniform Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1063, subsection 2, paragraph C make express references to the effect of dissociation on the partner's duties.
Subsection 3 accords with section 1554, subsection 2; dissociation does not entitle a person to any distribution or rights to force the limited liability company or its members to acquire the dissociated person's transferable interest.
SUBCHAPTER 8 - DISSOLUTION, WINDING UP, REINSTATEMENT AND REVIVAL
SECTION 1591. GROUNDS FOR ADMINISTRATIVE DISSOLUTION OF DOMESTIC LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
This section was derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1399.
SECTION 1592. PROCEDURE FOR AND EFFECT OF ADMINISTRATIVE DISSOLUTION OF DOMESTIC LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
This section was derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1399.
SECTION 1593. REINSTATEMENT FOLLOWING ADMINISTRATIVE DISSOLUTION OF DOMESTIC LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
This section was derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1400.
SECTION 1594. APPEAL FROM DENIAL OF REINSTATEMENT OF DOMESTIC LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
This section was derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1401.
SECTION 1595. EVENTS CAUSING DISSOLUTION
Subsection 2. In the close corporation context, many courts have reached this position without express statutory authority, most often with regard to court-ordered buyouts of oppressed shareholders. This subsection saves courts and litigants the trouble of reinventing that wheel in the LLC context. Paragraphs D and E of subsection 1 control even if the limited liability company provides otherwise. On the other hand, subsection 2 controls only if the limited liability company agreement does not provide otherwise. Thus, the members may agree to restrict or eliminate a court's power to craft a lesser remedy, even to the extent of confining the court and themselves to the all-or-nothing remedy of dissolution.
SECTION 1596. EFFECT OF DISSOLUTION
This section is derived from the Maine Business Corporation Act, Title 13-C, section 1405.
SECTION 1597. RIGHT TO WIND UP BUSINESS AND ACTIVITIES
It is important to remember that the designation of the person with authority to wind up the limited liability company may be determined in the limited liability company agreement. For example, the parties may determine to have a liquidating trustee take control on dissolution.
SECTION 1598. POWER TO BIND LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AFTER DISSOLUTION
The extent of the apparent authority of the person designated to wind up the affairs of the LLC and the person who had authority before dissolution is probably unaffected by the limited liability company agreement, that is, that person will have the power to bind the LLC to transactions inconsistent with winding up notwithstanding dissolution to a person dealing with the LLC without notice of the dissolution.
SECTION 1599. KNOWN CLAIMS AGAINST DISSOLVED LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
This section is derived from the Maine Business Corporation Act, Title 13-C, section 1406.
Subsection 4 was modified to add clarification regarding certain unliquidated claims and contingent liabilities.
SECTION 1600. OTHER CLAIMS AGAINST DISSOLVED LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
This section is derived from the Maine Business Corporation Act, Title 13-C, sections 1407 and 1408.
SECTION 1601. APPLICATION OF ASSETS IN WINDING UP LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY'S ACTIVITIES
This Act does not require that distributions in liquidation be made in cash.
Distributions made pursuant to this section are subject to outstanding charging orders under section 1573.
SECTION 1604. REVIVAL OF DOMESTIC LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AFTER DISSOLUTION
This section was derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1401-A.
SUBCHAPTER 9 - LOW-PROFIT LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANIES
Subchapter 9 is this State's first legislation addressing low-profit limited liability companies, L3Cs. L3Cs are a new form of entity merging a for-profit business model with charitable and educational objectives. Each L3C functions as a limited liability company with certain exceptions, such exceptions primarily stemming from the purpose of an L3C.
SECTION 1611. LOW-PROFIT LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
Section 1611, subsection 1 mandates that, in order to qualify as an L3C, each L3C must at all times significantly further the accomplishment of one or more of the charitable or educational purposes within Section 170(c)(2)(B) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986. Additionally, no significant purpose of an L3C can be the production of income or the appreciation of property and no purpose of the L3C can be the accomplishment of political or legislative purposes, as defined by Section 170(c)(2)(D) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986. Section 1611, subsection 2 requires that statements to the effect of the foregoing must be included in the certificate of formation and limited liability company act of each L3C, together with the specific Section 170(c)(2)(B) purposes it intends to further.
Under section 1611, subsection 3, if a company ceases to satisfy the requirements for an L3C, it continues to exist as an LLC, as long as it promptly amends its certificate of formation so that its purpose no longer identifies it as an L3C and its name no longer includes "L3C" or "low-profit limited liability company."
Another difference between an L3C and an LLC are the duties ascribed to the respective members and other managers of each. Section 1559 describes those duties, and section 1559, subsection 1 contains an accommodation for L3C members and managers by expressly expanding such historical fiduciary duties by allowing that the interests of each L3C and its members includes furthering the required L3C purposes as described in section 1611, subsection 2. Section 1611, subsection 4 establishes that each L3C is bound by the expanded section 1559.
Section 1611, subsection 5 provides that subchapter 9 does not prevent an LLC other than an L3C from electing a Section 170(c)(2)(B) purpose, in whole or part, for doing business.
SUBCHAPTER 10 - FOREIGN LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANIES
SECTION 1621. GOVERNING LAW
This section was derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1411.
SECTION 1622. STATEMENT OF FOREIGN QUALIFICATION TO CONDUCT ACTIVITIES REQUIRED
This section was derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, sections 1412 and 1412-A.
SECTION 1623. ACTIONS NOT CONSTITUTING TRANSACTING BUSINESS OR CONDUCTING ACTIVITIES
This section was derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1413.
SECTION 1625. GROUNDS FOR REVOCATION OF STATEMENT OF FOREIGN QUALIFICATION
This section was derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1416.
SECTION 1626. PROCEDURE FOR AND EFFECT OF REVOCATION
This section was derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1416.
SUBCHAPTER 11 - ACTIONS BY MEMBERS
SECTION 1631. DIRECT ACTION BY MEMBER
Subsection 1 is derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1421, subsection 1, which was based on the Maine Uniform Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1045, subsection 2. The subsection has been somewhat restyled from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act version, and the phrase "for legal or equitable relief" has been deleted as unnecessary. The Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act's reference to "with or without an accounting" has been deleted because the reference was to the partnership remedy of accounting, which reflected the aggregate nature of a partnership and is inapposite for an entity such as an LLC and generated some confusion with the equitable claim for an accounting in the nature of a constructive trust. The entity analog to the partnership-as-aggregate notion of an accounting is the distinction between a direct and derivative claim.
The last phrase of this subsection, which comes from the Maine Uniform Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1045, subsection 2, paragraph C, does not create any new rights, obligations or remedies, and is included merely to emphasize that a person's membership in an LLC does not preclude the person from enforcing rights existing independently of the membership relationship.
Subsection 2 is derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1421, subsection 2. The Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act Comment to that subsection explains:
In ordinary contractual situations it is axiomatic that each party to a contract has standing to sue for breach of that contract. Within a limited partnership, however, different circumstances may exist. A partner does not have a direct claim against another partner merely because the other partner has breached the operating agreement. Likewise a partner's violation of this Act does not automatically create a direct claim for every other partner. To have standing in his, her, or its own right, a partner plaintiff must be able to show a harm that occurs independently of the harm caused or threatened to be caused to the limited partnership.
SECTION 1632. DERIVATIVE ACTION
This section is derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1422.
SECTION 1633. PROPER PLAINTIFF
This section abandons the traditional contemporaneous ownership rule, on the theory that the protections of that rule are unnecessary given the closely held nature of most limited liability companies and the built-in, statutory restrictions on persons becoming members.
Subsection 2 is inapposite if the limited liability company has only 2 members, one of whom is the derivative plaintiff. In that limited circumstance, the plaintiff's death causes the derivative action to abate. The pick your partner principal in section 1572 prevents the decedent's heirs from succeeding to plaintiff status in the derivative action. This Act does not take a position on whether the death of a member abates a direct claim against the LLC or a fellow member.
SECTION 1634. PLEADING
This section is derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1424.
SECTION 1635. SPECIAL LITIGATION COMMITTEE
Although special litigation committees are best known in the corporate field, they are no more inherently corporate than derivative litigation or the notion that an organization is a person distinct from its owners. A special litigation committee can serve as an alternative dispute resolution mechanism, help protect an agreed-upon arrangement from strike suits, protect the interests of members who are neither plaintiffs nor defendants, if any, and bring to any judicial decision the benefits of a specially tailored business judgment.
This section's approach corresponds to established law in most jurisdictions, modified to fit the typical governance structures of a limited liability company.
Subsection 1. On the availability of section 1558 remedies pending the special litigation committee's investigation, compare Kaufman v. Computer Assoc. Int'l., Inc., No. Civ.A. 699-N, 2005 WL 3470589 at *1 (Del.Ch. Dec. 21, 2005, as revised), presenting "the question of whether to stay a books and records action under 8 Del. C. § 220 at the request of a special litigation committee when a derivative action encompassing substantially the same allegations of wrongdoing filed by different plaintiffs is pending in another jurisdiction;" concluding "[f]or reasons that have much to do with the light burden imposed by the plaintiff's demand in this case . . . that the special litigation committee's motion to stay the books and records action should be denied."
Subsection 4. The standard stated for judicial review of the special litigation committee determination follows Auerbach v. Bennett, 47 N.Y.2d 619, 419 N.Y.S.2d 920 (N.Y. 1979) rather than Zapata Corp. v. Maldonado, 430 A.2d 779 (Del. 1981), because the latter's reference to a court's business judgment has generally not been followed in other states.
Houle v. Low, 407 Mass. 810, 822, 556 N.E.2d 51, 58 (Mass. 1990) contains an excellent explanation of the court's role in reviewing a special litigation committee decision:
The value of a special litigation committee is coextensive with the extent to which that committee truly exercises business judgment. In order to ensure that special litigation committees do act for the [entity]'s best interest, a good deal of judicial oversight is necessary in each case. At the same time, however, courts must be careful not to usurp the committee's valuable role in exercising business judgment.
[A] special litigation committee must be independent, unbiased, and act in good faith. Moreover, such a committee must conduct a thorough and careful analysis regarding the plaintiff's derivative suit, ... The burden of proving that these procedural requirements have been met must rest, in all fairness, on the party capable of making that proof--the [entity].
For a discussion of how a court should approach the question of independence, see Einhorn v. Culea, 612 N.W.2d 78, 91 (Wis. 2000).
SECTION 1636. PROCEEDS AND EXPENSES
This section is derived from the Maine Uniform Limited Partnership Act, Title 31, section 1425.
SECTION 1637. CLOSELY HELD LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
This section is derived from TEXAS BUS. & COM. § 101.463.
SUBCHAPTER 12 - MERGER AND CONVERSION
SECTION 1645. CONVERSION
This section permits a foreign organization, including a foreign limited liability company, to convert to a Maine limited liability company. Thus, a foreign limited liability domesticates in Maine through the conversion process.
SUBCHAPTER 13 - ADMINISTRATIVE PROVISIONS
This subchapter contains filing, fees and other administrative provisions that are based on similar provisions in the predecessor Act.
SUBCHAPTER 14 - MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS
SECTION 1693. APPLICATION TO EXISTING RELATIONSHIPS
Subsection 2. When a preexisting limited liability company becomes subject to this Act, the company ceases to be governed by the predecessor Act, including whatever requirements that Act might have imposed for the contents of the articles of organization. However, as articles of organization will still be on file after the effective date of this Act, and as some may rely on the filings as a matter of habit, paragraph B provides that, solely for purposes of establishing apparent authority, the designation in the articles of organization is treated as incorporated into the limited liability company agreement. The limited liability company that wishes to eliminate the authority provided under paragraph B may file an amendment or restatement under section 1542.
Part B of this amendment corrects cross-references.
This Act takes effect July 1, 2011.